For all my TV Reviews I use the following categories. Results are then tallied and averaged to come up with the final score.
Core Television Elements
- Script (5 stars possible): Similar to the theatre system, consider plot originality, character development, dialogue quality, and overall effectiveness in conveying the story across multiple episodes (for serialized shows) or within single episodes (for episodic shows).
- Acting (5 stars possible): Evaluate the acting performances based on technical skills (delivery, emotional range, believability) and character embodiment.
- Directing (5 stars possible): Assess the director’s vision in translating the script to screen. Consider pacing, editing choices, shot composition, and overall style across multiple episodes (especially for serialized shows).
- Cinematography (5 stars possible): Evaluate the technical and artistic quality of the camerawork, lighting, shot selection, and use of color to create a visually engaging and immersive experience.
- Sound Design & Editing (5 stars possible): Consider the quality of the soundtrack, sound effects, and how effectively they create atmosphere, build tension, and support the story.
TV Show Specific Categories
- Special Effects (5 stars possible): Evaluate the seamlessness, believability, and impact of any visual effects used in the show, considering the show’s budget and genre.
- Production Design (5 stars possible): Consider the quality and effectiveness of the sets, costumes, props, and makeup in creating a believable world and supporting the story and characters.
- Music (5 stars possible): Evaluate the quality of the theme song, score, and any other music used in the show, and its effectiveness in setting mood and enhancing the narrative.
Viewing Experience
- Engagement (5 stars possible): Similar to the other systems, consider how well the show held your attention, evoked emotions, or sparked thought-provoking moments. Consider pacing across a season (for serialized shows) or within individual episodes (for episodic shows).
- Rewatchability (5 stars possible): Would you recommend watching the show again? Consider the show’s plot structure, character development, and overall entertainment value.
